Research Blog #9 - Argument & Counterargument

 My Argument:

In my paper, I explained that scientists like astrobiologists, ufologists, and astronomers of many different generations have tried their best to understand and learn about space and get a possible answer to the question: are we alone in the universe? Many conspiracy theorists have tried to use their observations and opinions to come up with different explanations as to whether or not aliens exist. But over decades, since the U.S. government started to search for extraterrestrial intelligence, the research and project did not have much progress, due to the boundary work between SETI scientists and ufologists and other external effects. The boundaries that hinder these scientists from collaborating with each other, limit the many possible discoveries on the outer space. 


A counter-argument of ufology being considered a pseudoscience is :

Ufologists are not just ordinary people who are digging information and analyzing their findings to understand things that they don't even know about. "In 1976 a survey was conducted among donors to the Center for UFO Studies in Evanston, Illinois. One-fifth of the 161 donors who answered the survey had Ph.D. degrees and a total of 75 percent has earned at least a bachelor's degree. The most common degrees were in physics engineering, but others covered the entire spectrum of academia -- there were even three with MLS degree." This quote is enough to explain that Ufologists is not just an ordinary person without a proper college degree who is interested in working on conspiracy theories. They are well-educated professionals that have learned enough data and information to consider themselves reliable researchers. 


Eberhart, G. M. (1980). UFO Literature for the Serious Ufologist. RQ, 144-148.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What Impacts would UFOs Bring?

Image
  Topics: What Impacts would UFOs Brings The occurrences of UFOs shock the whole of mankind in the first place. We thought we were the only living intelligent creatures in the universe before those extraterrestrials visited Earth. Fear, anxiety, and curiosity flowed into our minds all of a sudden. Different reactions and behaviors were made, and some diverse thoughts of the authenticity of UFOs spread through society. It is interesting to observe how will humankind dealing with such major events by various approaches. 
Read more

Scouting the Territory

Image
 The main idea of the topic, "what impact does UFO have on our society" hasn't changed. At first, my opinion only remain at the level of government's pressure on the public, but it evolves to some perspectives such as the existence of extraterrestrials lead the assumption of more high civilizations outside the solar system (https://www.wired.com/story/what-scientists-can-learn-from-alien-hunters/) and some potential cultural impact of UFOs contact.  (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potential_cultural_impact_of_extraterrestrial_contact).  Key terms like "UFO culture" and "Impact of UFO Technology" I put into google comes out some websites like "what happens next if we find proof of space aliens". But all the articles were talking about due to the restriction of current technology on finding the exact proof on extraterrestrials, there are no assumptions of the next step of human beings. But there is an article talking about "what scienti
Read more

Research Blog #7: Theoretical Frame

Image
  My theoretical frame is based on the article, "What Can Scientists Learn from Alien Hunters". It organizes the fields of studies where astrobiologists and astronomers were on, based on their methods of systematic experimentation. The article directly points out the reason for the boundary work was because of their various approaches to scientific researches on extraterrestrials life topics. By analyzing their methods on scientific studies and looking deep at some political influences, I could conclude with how does the boundary-work affects the study progress on extraterrestrial life for over decades. 
Read more